
Following recent media coverage of controversial claims about the “myth” of dyslexia
Professor Arnold Wilkins, Head of the Visual Perception Unit at the University of
Essex replies : “I would argue that the jury is still out.
It is quite unclear what
dyslexia is due to and it is unlikely to be just one thing. Reading is a complex
visual, phonological, linguistic and cognitive skill and might be expect to fail
for a large number of reasons. It may be more appropriate to concentrate on the
reasons for reading failure than on the classification of individuals with such
failure. Visual stress can certainly be one of the reasons for reading failure,
using special filters to reduce head pain with which reading is associated can sometimes
turn a reluctant reader into an avid reader overnight with consequences for reading
acquisition. Some 20% of unselected children in mainstream education ( not simply
those with reading difficulties) find coloured overlays/ filters of benefit and
the benefit is pronounced in 5%.
The label of dyslexia provides children who are
failing at school with an ‘explanation’ of their difficulty. This is not an excuse
for failure so much as a reason for specialist intervention. But it is also much
more than this, it is a means of restoring a child’s self esteem, and should not
be lightly set aside.”
Optometry Today Published 2005-10-07
I would draw attention to the results from Go With the Gobbies trials in schools and in particular to the high percentage (93%) of children who stated the reading Trackograph had helped them to read fluently. And of course, success breeds success!